Connect with us

Latest

JONATHAN TURLEY: Comey’s shell post may be crass, but charging him is a free speech trap

Published

on

In the last year, coverage of former FBI Director James Comey appears to be reverting to the level of a high school yearbook. Last March, we were discussing how Comey channeled Beyoncé in a classified meeting and then may have revealed a code name in an encore performance for family. Now we are back to discussing Comey’s beach shell art on social media.

The latter controversy is now at the heart of a second criminal indictment of Comey. In November, a court dismissed the first indictment for false statements after a challenge to the status of the acting U.S. attorney.

However, this indictment is being brought in North Carolina, the location of the beach where the offending shells were found. Comey will now likely create a new category of protected shell speech.

The problem with this indictment will be the merits. The indictment concerns an image that was later removed by Comey showing “86 47” in shells on a beach. Comey has a rather odd history of drawing inspiration from shells. This message, however, had a lethal twist since many interpreted the message as essentially calling for the killing or “86-ing” of Trump.

JAMES COMEY INDICTED FOR ALLEGED THREATS AGAINST TRUMP: DOJ

📣

FROM THE EDITORS  -  Keeping our readers safe extends beyond the headlines. We've secured an exclusive antivirus offer from TotalAV to help protect your devices and personal information.

Comey insists that he did not make the shell art and that he only posted it to his more than 1 million followers on X. He was merely the captive of his shell muses.

For over a decade, I have been one of Comey’s most vocal and consistent critics. I have dozens of columns criticizing his excesses and the damage that he has done to our system.

For that reason, I would prefer to crawl into one of Comey’s conversant shells than write a column supporting him. However, here we are. The fact is that I believe that this indictment is facially unconstitutional absent some unknown new facts.

To convict Comey, the Justice Department will have to show that his adolescent picture was a “true threat” under 18 U.S.C. § 871 and § 875(c). It is not.

FBI LAUNCHES CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS OF JOHN BRENNAN, JAMES COMEY: DOJ SOURCES

The First Amendment is designed to protect unpopular speech. Popular speech rarely needs protection. It also protects bad and hateful speech. It even protects lies so long as those lies are not used for the purpose of fraud or other criminal conspiracies.

In 1969, the Supreme Court declared a more direct threat protected under the First Amendment. In Watts v. United States, an 18-year-old anti-war protester exclaimed, “If they ever make me carry a rifle the first man I want to get in my sights is L. B. J.”

While the court did rule that “the statute [criminalizing presidential threats] is constitutional on its face,” it emphasized that “what is a threat must be distinguished from what is constitutionally protected speech.”

The court ruled that the expression of wanting to kill a president is “a kind of very crude offensive method of stating a political opposition to the President.” Saying the same thing in shell is only further removed from criminal speech.

Citizens are allowed to denounce and even wish a president ill. I have written about what I called this “age of rage.” It is not our first. This nation was founded in rage. The Boston Tea Party was rage. In forming this more perfect union, we created the world’s greatest protection of free speech in history. It is arguably the most American contribution to our Bill of Rights. Great Britain did not — and still does not — protect free speech as we do.

TRUMP SAYS COMEY ‘PLACED A CLOUD OVER THE ENTIRE NATION’ WITH CROSSFIRE HURRICANE, REACTS TO INDICTMENT

It comes at a cost. Perhaps Comey is that cost. However, he has a right to write out any hateful thoughts that come to him on his walks on the beach.

A true threat requires “statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals.” Virginia v. Black, 538 U.S. 343, 359 (2003).

It is certainly true that the threat can be implied. However, “The ‘true’ in that term distinguishes what is at issue from jests, ‘hyperbole,’ or other statements that when taken in context do not convey a real possibility that violence will follow.” Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66, 74 (2023).

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

At the time, Comey quickly deleted the post and said that it never occurred to him that it would be interpreted as being violent.

In a subsequent Instagram post, Comey said he assumed the shells that he saw on a beach walk were “a political message” and that he “did not realize some folks associate those numbers with violence.”

We will have to wait to see if the administration has a “smoking shell” allegation that makes Comey’s shell speech more menacing as a willful and knowing threat. I cannot imagine what that would be beyond a sleeper surfer hit squad waiting for a shell signal.

Absent such new evidence, it appears to be yet another Comey posting that makes his Beyoncé renditions seem professional in comparison.

Ironically, the indictment is unlikely to survive a challenge, but it is likely to fulfill Comey’s narrative about the administration. It will undermine the legitimate objections to the lawfare waged under Comey.

Comey’s shell speech should not be celebrated, but it should be protected.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM JONATHAN TURLEY

Continue Reading

Latest

WH Swiftly Seizes Phones On Air Force One Amidst Sudden Secret Move

Published

on

WH Swiftly Seizes Phones On Air Force One Amidst Sudden Secret Move

An unusual security measure aboard Air Force One has sparked speculation about President Donald Trump’s travel plans after U.S. officials reportedly confiscated reporters’ cellphones as the president departed China on Thursday.

The unexpected move came as Trump wrapped up a high-profile diplomatic visit involving Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, raising questions about whether the president might be preparing for an unannounced stop before returning to Washington.

Reporters traveling with the president were instructed to surrender their mobile devices as Air Force One prepared to depart Shenzhen Bao’an International Airport.

Agence France-Presse correspondent Aurelia End confirmed the unusual development in a White House press pool dispatch.

“Our phones are being taken away for now for security reasons,” End wrote.

📣

FROM THE EDITORS  -  Keeping our readers safe extends beyond the headlines. We've secured an exclusive antivirus offer from TotalAV to help protect your devices and personal information.

The directive immediately attracted attention from journalists accustomed to traveling aboard the presidential aircraft.

NBC News correspondent Garrett Haake highlighted the unusual nature of the restriction in a post on X.

“This is very unusual,” Haake wrote.

Fox News White House correspondent Jacqui Heinrich also raised questions about the president’s itinerary, pointing to another development involving a potential refueling stop in Alaska.

According to Heinrich, the combination of reporters being required to surrender their phones and the lifting of a flight restriction associated with a possible Alaska stop suggested that Air Force One “may not be heading straight home.”

The president’s publicly released schedule identified Joint Base Andrews in Maryland as his destination following the China visit.

However, it remained unclear whether Air Force One would make an additional stop before arriving in the Washington, D.C., area.

The secrecy surrounding the departure revived speculation about a possible diplomatic encounter involving North Korean leader Kim Jong Un.

Before departing Washington earlier in the week, Trump had publicly discussed the possibility of meeting Kim during his trip to China.

“We may meet with Kim Jong Un,” Trump told reporters at the White House on Monday.

The president indicated that any such meeting would take place in China and suggested that Chinese President Xi Jinping would play a role in determining whether the North Korean leader participated.

Despite those remarks, no meeting between Trump and Kim had been announced by the time the president departed China on Thursday.

There was also no official confirmation that the unusual cellphone restrictions were connected to North Korea or any other potential diplomatic engagement.

Still, the security precautions stood out because of how they differed from procedures during previous presidential travel.

Heinrich noted that journalists were allowed to retain their phones when Trump departed Beijing during a visit in May.

During that earlier trip, the White House press pool reported that American personnel discarded Chinese-issued badges and pins, along with temporary phones used by White House staff, before boarding the presidential aircraft.

Those precautions highlighted concerns about communications security during international travel, particularly when U.S. officials operate in countries where electronic surveillance is a significant consideration.

Thursday’s reported collection of reporters’ personal phones represented a different and more restrictive measure.

The departure followed an extraordinary diplomatic gathering involving the leaders of the United States, China and Russia.

Hours before boarding Air Force One, Trump participated in his first three-way meeting with Xi and Putin on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.

The discussions reportedly included nuclear arms control and the ongoing war involving Iran, placing several major international security issues at the center of the talks.

The meeting brought together three leaders whose governments play significant roles in global military affairs, nuclear policy and international diplomacy.

Access to the diplomatic discussions was tightly controlled, with several journalists reportedly prevented from attending portions of the meetings.

NBC News reported that Russian officials turned away two journalists seeking access to Trump’s separate meeting with Putin.

Chinese officials also reportedly barred Bloomberg correspondent Annmarie Hordern from attending the three-way discussions after she shouted a question concerning former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang during Trump’s earlier meeting with Xi.

The restrictions underscored the limited access granted to journalists covering the sensitive diplomatic encounters.

During his earlier meeting with Xi, Trump commented on the press missing part of the proceedings, telling the Chinese president that it was unfortunate because “every move was perfectly executed.”

The president’s remarks came amid an itinerary involving discussions with two of the world’s most consequential geopolitical figures.

By the time Air Force One departed Shenzhen, however, attention had shifted from the meetings themselves to the unusual security procedures aboard the aircraft.

The confiscation of reporters’ phones, combined with questions about a possible Alaska refueling stop, fueled uncertainty about the president’s immediate destination.

Although Trump’s official schedule called for a return to Joint Base Andrews, the developments prompted speculation that his diplomatic trip might not yet be over.

For now, the reason for the cellphone restrictions and whether Air Force One would make an unscheduled stop remained unconfirmed.

Until the White House provides additional details, the unusual departure procedures remain a source of questions rather than evidence of a confirmed change in the president’s itinerary.

Continue Reading

Latest

Democrat Politician Indicted By Federal Grand Jury

Published

on

Democrat Politician Indicted By Federal Grand Jury

An Alabama Democratic state lawmaker is facing four federal wire fraud charges after prosecutors accused him of fraudulently obtaining more than $240,000 in taxpayer-funded pandemic relief assistance and diverting money intended for struggling organizations toward personal expenses.

State Rep. Patrick Sellers, D-Pleasant Grove, was indicted by a federal grand jury in connection with an alleged scheme involving multiple COVID-19 assistance programs, including funds distributed through the Small Business Administration.

Federal prosecutors allege that Sellers submitted fraudulent applications to obtain government assistance before using portions of the money to pay personal credit card bills, mortgage expenses and college tuition for his daughters.

Sellers, who has represented Alabama’s House District 57 since November 2022, also serves as pastor of Mount Zion Missionary Baptist Church in Birmingham.

The alleged offenses occurred between July 2020 and May 2021, before Sellers entered the Alabama Legislature, while he was serving as chief of staff to the president of the Alabama State Missionary Baptist Convention.

📣

FROM THE EDITORS  -  Keeping our readers safe extends beyond the headlines. We've secured an exclusive antivirus offer from TotalAV to help protect your devices and personal information.

U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama Phil Williams announced the indictment Thursday, indicating that prosecutors believe they have substantial evidence supporting the charges.

“This is certainly not all the evidence. This is a very robust indictment, and certainly would be a robust trial,” Williams said.

Each of the four wire fraud counts carries a maximum statutory penalty of 20 years in federal prison. If convicted, Sellers could face significant prison time, although any sentence would depend on the court’s findings and applicable federal sentencing guidelines.

According to the indictment, Sellers allegedly exploited several federal pandemic relief programs by submitting applications connected to the Baptist convention’s nonprofit organization, another nonprofit called Project Zion Inc., and a purported lawn care company.

Prosecutors identified the lawn care operation, Sellers Lawn Care, as “a fictitious business entity.”

Federal investigators allege that the applications resulted in approximately $105,000 in assistance connected to the convention’s nonprofit organization, another $114,900 associated with Project Zion and $20,415 obtained through a Paycheck Protection Program loan.

Together, the payments exceeded $240,000 in federal assistance intended to support businesses and organizations experiencing financial hardship during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The indictment also describes allegations that Sellers began improperly exercising control over financial accounts associated with the Baptist convention’s nonprofit operations as early as 2019.

Prosecutors claim Sellers established a bank account using the organization’s name but listed his personal residence in Pleasant Grove rather than the organization’s headquarters in Selma.

Investigators further allege that he created a separate email account and changed the nonprofit organization’s mailing address with the Internal Revenue Service.

Those actions allegedly allowed Sellers to direct communications and financial transactions involving the organization without authorization from its leadership.

In July 2020, Sellers allegedly submitted an application for a $20,000 Small Business Administration disaster loan on behalf of the convention’s nonprofit organization.

Federal prosecutors maintain that he did so without obtaining permission from the organization’s leadership.

The application represented that the federal assistance would be used “solely as working capital to alleviate economic injury caused by [the COVID-19] disaster.”

However, investigators allege that Sellers instead directed substantial portions of the money toward personal financial obligations.

According to the indictment, approximately $11,286.75 went toward payments on personal credit card accounts, while another $1,000 was allegedly used to pay his mother’s water bill.

The allegations raise questions about how federal relief funds intended for nonprofit operations were obtained and subsequently spent.

Prosecutors contend that the transactions were part of a broader effort to obtain pandemic assistance through applications that misrepresented the nature of the organizations involved or Sellers’ authority to act on their behalf.

The convention’s president eventually discovered the Small Business Administration loan and contacted the agency, according to the allegations.

The case centers on federal assistance programs established during the pandemic to help businesses and nonprofit organizations survive severe economic disruptions.

Those programs distributed substantial amounts of taxpayer money through loans and other forms of financial support, creating opportunities for legitimate applicants while also exposing the government to fraudulent claims.

In Sellers’ case, federal authorities allege that money intended to address pandemic-related financial hardship was instead diverted for expenses unrelated to the purposes of the assistance programs.

The indictment places the Alabama lawmaker under federal criminal scrutiny over conduct that prosecutors say occurred before he assumed elected office.

While the charges carry potentially serious consequences, the allegations have not been proven in court. Sellers is presumed innocent unless and until prosecutors establish his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The case will now proceed through the federal judicial system, where prosecutors will be required to substantiate the allegations outlined in the indictment.

Continue Reading

Latest

JUST IN: Mamdani Rushed To The Hospital — Had It Coming!

Published

on

JUST IN: Mamdani Rushed To The Hospital — Had It Coming!

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani suffered a torn Achilles tendon during a friendly soccer match against members of the City Hall press corps Thursday night, leaving the 35-year-old mayor on crutches and facing months of recovery.

What began as a lighthearted competition between City Hall officials and reporters ended with Mamdani being helped off the field and his security detail reportedly scrambling to locate the nearest hospital.

The mayor had entered the indoor soccer match without stretching beforehand, something he later acknowledged while discussing the injury.

Despite the lack of preparation, Mamdani got off to a strong start, scoring a goal shortly after joining the game.

His night took a painful turn during the second half when he went down while chasing the ball. According to accounts of the incident, no opposing player made contact with Mamdani before he suffered the injury.

📣

FROM THE EDITORS  -  Keeping our readers safe extends beyond the headlines. We've secured an exclusive antivirus offer from TotalAV to help protect your devices and personal information.

The sudden collapse brought his participation in the match to an immediate end.

City Hall staffers assisted the injured mayor out of the facility as members of his security detail were reportedly overheard asking about the location of the nearest hospital, according to the New York Post.

By Friday morning, Mamdani was relying on crutches and a walking boot as he continued carrying out his official responsibilities.

The mayor reportedly used a wheelchair before his scheduled news conference and ultimately addressed reporters while seated on a stool, with a protective medical boot covering his right foot.

According to WABC, Mamdani said he expected to wear the walking boot for approximately six to eight weeks while recovering from the injury.

His return to recreational soccer, however, is expected to take considerably longer.

The mayor indicated that he does not anticipate getting back onto the soccer field for approximately nine months, reflecting the lengthy rehabilitation often associated with an Achilles tendon tear.

Despite the painful ending, Mamdani’s team managed to claim victory over the reporters.

The mayor told the New York Post that City Hall defeated the press corps by a final score of 10-5.

The injury did not prevent Mamdani from moving forward with a major policy announcement Friday involving the future of New York City’s troubled Rikers Island jail complex.

Appearing before reporters while visibly dealing with the aftermath of his soccer injury, Mamdani unveiled a proposal that would keep Rikers Island operating through the end of 2032.

The proposed timeline would extend the jail complex’s operation more than five years beyond the existing August 31, 2027, closure deadline.

Such an extension would require action from the New York City Council, which would have to amend city law to authorize the later closing date.

The announcement represents a significant development in the city’s longstanding effort to replace the aging Rikers Island facility with smaller, borough-based detention centers.

Under the mayor’s proposal, four replacement jails would eventually take over the functions currently handled by Rikers Island.

The first of those facilities is scheduled to open in Brooklyn in 2029, according to the plan.

The administration also outlined additional spending intended to address several issues affecting the city’s criminal justice system.

City Hall plans to allocate $146 million during the next fiscal year toward mental health treatment, addiction services, education, employment training and assistance for crime victims.

The proposal comes as New York City continues confronting questions about jail conditions, public safety, inmate services and the feasibility of replacing Rikers Island within the existing legal deadline.

Extending the closure date would give the city additional time to complete its planned replacement facilities, although the proposal cannot take effect without approval from lawmakers.

For Mamdani, Friday’s announcement also marked an unusual public appearance, with the mayor discussing one of the city’s most consequential correctional policies while recovering from an injury sustained during a recreational soccer game.

Although his administration secured a victory on the field Thursday night, the mayor’s personal outcome was far less fortunate.

Mamdani now faces weeks in a walking boot and potentially nine months away from soccer as he continues managing the responsibilities of New York City’s government.

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2026 Political Signal